BookBub is an online service that publicizes and sells new books. Customers can sign up to receive “Readworthy” emails containing brief information on new books in various categories: mysteries, novels, nonfiction books, etc. A recent email listed “This month’s best new Christian fiction.” When I perused the list, I discovered that every one of the books was a Christian romance.
Really?
Is this the best that Christians can do? Christians have the greatest vision of the world, and all we can talk about is romantic love?
Now, I am not blaming the writers of these novels. I am acquainted with some of these writers. They take their craft seriously. They produce formula fiction, but they often use this format to address significant issues—generational sin, incest, grief, and more. They follow in the footsteps and take their inspiration from the Brontes and Jane Austen, mainstream novelists of the 19th century.
The few Christian men writing novels nowadays also often write formulaic works, dealing especially with the end times.
But who am I to criticize? I also have mostly written formula fiction, murder mysteries, although, like the Christian romance novelists, I have tried to use formulaic fiction to address larger issues.
But this is not all we should be writing and certainly not all that Christians have written in the past.
Christians have produced that kind of literature in the past. Here are just a few examples that have inspired and challenged me.
Sir Gawain and the Green Knight is a beautiful and profound long narrative poem written by an unknown author in the Middle Ages. It is a literary masterpiece rarely equaled and was still being read and studied in the last century. Unfortunately, it was written in Old English, and I have yet to see a modern translation that does it justice. It is almost worth learning Old English in order to read it.
Joseph Conrad’s Heart of Darkness is a profound analysis of human depravity.
I don’t know that the short story writer O. Henry was a Christian, but his “The Gift of the Magi” is a classic Christmas story and a profound depiction of self-sacrificing love.
Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol is another Christmas classic that continues to inspire generosity.
Dostoevsky’s Crime and Punishment and Tolstoy’s Family Happiness are among their many works with Christian elements. Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn followed in their footsteps, with novels such as One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich.
There have been many great Christian poets, such as Robert Browning, whose long poems are character-driven stories.
J.R.R. Tolkien’s Lord of the Rings and C.S. Lewis’s Narnia books and other novels have obviously endured.
In North America, Catherine Marshall’s Christy is a book that goes far beyond the romances written by many modern Christian authors.
In our own times, John Grisham writes mostly formulaic (and very good) mainstream courtroom dramas but at times he has produced novels that could be considered great Christian literature. The Firm and The King of Torts illustrate the insidious corruption of greed. The Chamber looks at sin and guilt in a profound way. The Testament is one of the clearest expositions of the difference between secular and Christian life.
These are works that have impacted me. I am sure other readers could cite other books, both current works and works from previous centuries. Throughout the centuries, Christians have produced great literature that has had a profound impact on mainstream society. But we rarely achieve that today.
Why don’t we at least try to do better? It is a challenge worth considering. As stated, I have mostly written formula fiction, murder mysteries. However, my novel 1995, seldom read and even less often understood, was an attempt to do something more. My latest book, The Cabin and other stories, is a collection of short stories that at least attempts to move beyond formulaic fiction. I will leave it to others to determine how far I have succeeded.
The point is not that I have tried. The point is why more Christian writers have not tried. It is a challenge to myself and the many other Christian writers to aim higher.








































































